Truth Matters
This event series is part of the University of Cologne’s contribution to the 25th anniversary of the Scholars At Risk network. With Truth Matters, we reaffirm our commitment to academic freedom and the protection of threatened scholars. What does it mean to pursue knowledge when the home country becomes dangerous, inaccessible, or lost? And how do political turmoil and global conflict impact Universities?
The University of Cologne has a strong commitment to support at-risk scholars. It has been part of the worldwide Scholars at Risk network since 2015 and founding member of the Scholars at Risk Germany Section.
The University’s commitment to supporting international scholars who cannot pursue their research due to restrictions on their academic freedom, persecution, or war, requires the need to look at the world as a whole and local realities simultaneously.
Event Recap
The Crisis of Georgian Universities – Causes, Consequences and Futures
A panel discussion with guests from the University of Cologne’s partner institution Ilia State University.
“If you [are] independent you will have your budget, your income from students. But they don’t want [that]. You should be depended on the government’s decisions” - Elene Zhuravliova (Dean of the Faculty of Natural Sciences and Medicine, Ilia State University)
On 20 May, scholars, students, and members of the public gathered at the International House for an event of the Cologne International Forum’s Truth Matters series. “The Crisis of Georgian Universities: Causes, Consequences and Futures” shed light on the profound transformations currently affecting Georgia's higher education system and their implications for academic freedom, international co-operation, and democratic development....
The afternoon started off with a keynote address by Elene Zhuravliova, a representative of Ilia State University, providing first-hand insights on Georgia’s ongoing Higher Education Reform and the resulting challenges for institutional autonomy. Against the backdrop of these political developments – including the suspension of Georgia's EU accession negotiations and legislative changes affecting civil society – the keynote highlighted the government's increasing efforts to erode the academic landscape. This includes centralizing control over universities’ day-to-day business as well as budget plans: “we still don’t know what kind of money we will have in September” (Elene Zhuravliova). Furthermore, the government is gradually reducing choices in study programs and limiting student enrolment quotas: “our vacant places compared to the previous year [were] reduced by 92%”. Last but not least, a one city-one faculty rule was introduced which “will cause this brain drain among young researchers but also among professors. The number of professors also will be reduced […] in the next several years”.
The subsequent panel discussion brought together Prof. Dr. Christina Bogner (University of Cologne, Vice Dean of the Faculty of Mathematics and Natural Sciences), Prof. Dr. Mikheil Elashvili (Ilia State University), Dr. Nils Hein (Helmholtz Centre for Environmental Research, UFZ), and Dr. Hannes Laermanns (University of Cologne). Drawing on their extensive experience in international and interdisciplinary co-operation between Germany and Georgia, the speakers explored the far-reaching consequences of the reforms for students, researchers, university staff, and long-standing partnerships.
The discussion emphasized that restrictions on institutional independence not only threaten scientific excellence and open research collaboration but also have broader societal implications. Universities play a crucial role in fostering critical thinking, innovation, and democratic values, making the current transformations a matter of international concern.
“It’s about keeping Georgia connected to the European values, to the European standards, to the […] similar way we are looking to the future [–] that’s essential” (Prof. Dr. Mikheil Elashvili).
Throughout the event, participants engaged in a fruitful exchange on the future of the Georgian higher education system and the importance of maintaining strong international networks in times of political uncertainty. The discussion underscored the responsibility of the academic community to support colleagues facing increasing political pressure and to safeguard the principles of free speech.
The event highlighted the value of continued dialogue and cross-border partnerships, demonstrating that the latter remains an essential pillar for resilient and independent higher education. “What we can do: […] hold on to ongoing co-operations, at least for the scientific part, [and] show that we are doing it” (Prof Dr. Christina Bogner).
Event Recap
Truth Matters: Exile and Academia
Keynote Speech by Amira Ahmed (University of Cologne)
Panel discussion with Angelika Nußberger (University of Cologne), Samer Alkarkoukly (University Hospital Cologne, Board Member German-Syrian Research Society), Denis Yagodin (CTO, Araminta)
“Choosing to preserve your intellectual integrity by leaving an unsafe environment is not passive victimhood. It is a radical assertion of agency”. – Dr. Amira Ahmed (University of Cologne)
When a presidential executive order blocked the mobility of Sudanese citizens, Dr. Amira Ahmed, a Sudanese scholar and practitioner with extensive global expertise in migration and refugee studies, “became literally a prisoner in the US, for nothing else but due to [her] nationality”. This would be the first of two times that she was forced to become a ‘scholar at risk’, where academic itineraries, instead of in the peaceful quiet of university libraries, are “drafted in the margins of geopolitical shifts, rewritten by restrictive border policies, and disrupted by the sudden eruption of conflict”....
On June 9, Dr. Amira Ahmed brought her story to the Cologne International Forum as part of the series Truth Matters, a contribution to the 25th anniversary of the Scholars at Risk network. Together with Director of the Academy for European Human Rights Protection, Angelika Nußberger (University of Cologne), Denis Yagodin (CTO, Araminta), and Syrian researcher Samer Alkarkoukly (University Hospital Cologne, Board Member German-Syrian Research Society), we discussed the hardships and implications of forced displacement in the realm of academia.
Samer Alkarkoukly, a syrian medical researcher with a focus on data management talked about support offers that the German-Syrian Research Society provides, and discussed how academics become a target of repression, and also what challenges researchers phase, when they have to emigrate. Denis Yagodin, a specialist for digital security, pointed out how transnational repression is affecting academics and human rights activists.
The experiences shared by the scholars highlight how displacement and the struggle for survival disrupt the pursuit of a conventional academic careers. Professorships, uninterrupted publishing, permanent institutional affiliations – all these, according to Dr. Amira Ahmed, are luxuries for the displaced scholar, who is systematically excluded from these milestones. As such, academic solidarity “cannot just be an act of charity”, and we must recognize that the international migration regime is marked by structural inequalities that provide temporary relief but lack long-term security, requiring adaptation and productivity under conditions of ongoing precarity.
However, the key takeaway from this panel was to make voices heard and to reflect on academia in a fragile state. Instead, Dr. Amira Ahmed called it a “manifestation of resilience”. On a final hopeful note, she appealed to scholars at-risk “to look at this trajectory not as a deficit, but as a unique epistemic vantage point”, and urged the audience to “keep writing, keep speaking, and keep resisting”.
Event Recap
Iran – Historical Relations, Proxies, and the Question of International Accountability
Moderator: Prof. Fabian Klose (University of Cologne)
Panel discussion with Prof. Katajun Amirpur (University of Cologne), Dr. Ali Fathollah-Nejad (Center for Middle East and Global Order), Prof. Felix Lange (University of Cologne)
The University of Cologne is host and academic home to many researchers and students from Iran. The University's At-Risk Scholar Support, in turn, serves as a point of contact for researchers who feel directly threatened in their home country, and deals directly with assessing threat situations and their implications....
With the panel discussion "Iran – Historical Relations, Proxies, and the Question of International Accountability," we took a targeted look at the background, delving into the military confrontation between Iran, the USA, and Israel, along with its causes and consequences.
Our experts offered insight into Iran's position within the framework of international law and explored how historical relations have shaped its current geopolitical stance. On the panel were Professor Katajun Amirpur, scholar of Islamic studies, political scientist Dr. Ali Fathollah-Nejad, and Felix Lange, professor of international law, moderated by Prof. Fabian Klose.
We examined Iran not only from the West's security-policy perspective, but also from the perspective of the population's and the regime's own self-understanding.
Iranians have been confronted with their country's political upheavals for decades. They resisted, repeatedly adapted, and most recently, following the "Woman, Life, Freedom" uprisings, defended themselves against a violent regime with an even larger protest movement.
The regime's response to the protests, marked by massive violence, initially appeared — at least rhetorically — to be the spark for US intervention, underpinned by the constant threat posed by Iran's nuclear ambitions. Subsequently, the US and Israel opted against humanitarian engagement and in favor of the use of force.
From an international law perspective, Felix Lange made clear how shaky the American justification of self-defense is. The right to self-defense under the UN Charter applies only in the case of an armed attack, not a mere "threat," as was asserted before the United Nations — particularly since even the International Atomic Energy Agency could not provide evidence of a systematic weapons program. His conclusion: violations of international law on both sides.
Yet even where the guns have fallen silent, peace remains fragile, as Ali Fathollah-Nejad made clear. The current agreement is not a peace agreement, he said, but merely aims to end the "hot war." Law alone, he argued, explains little when institutions hide behind it instead of pursuing policies that genuinely help people on the ground. He summed up the consequences as an "economic disaster" — a phrase for a reality that has long since taken on a weight of its own.
Katajun Amirpur's perspective illustrated just how much this reality affects people on the ground, describing a population caught between two feelings: relief that open war is over for now, and concern about being left alone once again with a now more emboldened regime. Amirpur pointed out that had the war been brief and caused few civilian casualties, the question of its illegality under international law would likely have been secondary for many Iranians anyway.
Our discussion moved within precisely this tension between legal assessment and lived political reality, and it continued among the audience. In the end, the evening offered fewer simple answers than a vivid picture of the conflict's complexity — between international law and political reality, between geopolitical interests and the everyday lives of people in Iran.